How We Work
Editorial Policy
The standards behind every review, comparison and buying guide on Premium Pickleball Gear, including the exact rating scale we use for every paddle.
Research, Not Hands-On Testing
Premium Pickleball Gear is a research publication. We don’t play-test, measure or weigh paddles. Every score on this site comes from published information and a fixed scoring formula, not from time on court. As a new website, we hope to add play-tested reviews in the near future. When we do, the review will say so plainly and show what we did. Until then, no review on this site claims hands-on testing.
Our Editorial Standards
- Independent research. We decide what to cover and what to recommend. No manufacturer or retailer reviews our content before it’s published.
- Transparent specifications. We record the same specifications for every paddle and say where each figure comes from.
- Clear pros and cons. Every review states a paddle’s weaknesses as plainly as its strengths.
- What the specs mean. We explain what a paddle’s specifications mean on court, and what verified buyers consistently report on the manufacturer’s site.
- Fair comparisons. Every paddle is scored on the same scale, so comparisons are fair across brands.
- Regularly updated. We revisit reviews and best-of lists and show when each was last updated.
What Evidence We Use
| Source | What we take from it | How we use it |
|---|---|---|
| The manufacturer’s published specs (product page and spec table) | Weight, dimensions, core thickness and material, face material, surface, handle length, and swing and twist weight where published | The facts every score is built from. We credit each figure to the brand |
| The manufacturer’s product description | Construction and technology details, such as “thermoformed”, “grit coating” or “longer-lasting spin” | Credited to the brand in the review, for example “Selkirk says…” |
| The USA Pickleball approved paddle list | Whether a paddle is approved for sanctioned play, and the date it was added | Shown in each review so you know where it’s legal to play, and as the paddle’s “First approved” date |
| The UPA-A approved paddle list | Whether a paddle is approved for PPA Tour and MLP pro events, and the date it was added | Shown in each review, and used for the “First approved” date when a paddle isn’t on the USA Pickleball list yet |
| The USA Pickleball Equipment Standards Manual and the UPA-A paddle specifications | The limits every approved paddle must meet: size, weight, thickness, surface roughness (grit) and, for UPA-A, spin | Used in our guides to explain what the rules allow. These bodies publish limits and pass/fail lists, not measurements for individual paddles, so our scores still come from each maker’s specs. Neither body reviews or endorses this site |
| Buyer ratings and comments on the manufacturer’s own store | The average star rating, a rounded-down count (e.g. “450+”), the common themes, how many reviews mention power, control, spin or the sweet spot, and an occasional short quote | Shared in each review so you hear from real players, credited to the brand’s store. Our scores come from the specs alone |
We don’t use test results, ratings or reviews from other review or affiliate websites.
Where Each Detail Comes From
Each review labels where its information comes from:
- “Manufacturer data”: a published specification, such as weight or core thickness.
- “Manufacturer description” or “[Brand] says…”: details from the brand’s own product description, such as a heat-sealed build or a grit surface. Some of these earn scoring points, and the review credits them to the brand.
- “Our analysis”: our scoring formula applied to the specs above.
- “Buyer feedback”: what customers say on the brand’s own store, shared for context.
Because we research rather than play-test, we credit every detail to its source, so you always know what comes from the maker and what is our own analysis.
How We Use AI
We use AI tools in our research and writing. They help us gather each manufacturer’s published specifications, prices and buyer ratings, apply our rating scale consistently across every paddle, and draft our reviews, comparisons and guides.
A person is responsible for everything we publish. Dan, our editor, sets the rating scale and the rules our reviews follow, chooses which paddles and topics we cover, spot-checks reviews against their sources, and approves every page before it goes live.
What doesn’t change:
- Every specification comes from the manufacturer, and every review lists its sources.
- Every score comes from the same published rating scale, not from an AI’s opinion.
- We never claim hands-on testing we haven’t done.
- Brands don’t pay for placement or scores.
Our Rating Scale
Every paddle gets four scores out of 10: power, control, spin and sweet spot. Each one starts at 7, then goes up or down depending on how the paddle is built. We use the maker’s own published facts and score every paddle the same way.
Why every paddle starts at 7: a 7 means a solid paddle with nothing extra: none of the specs that earn points, such as a thin or foam core, an elongated shape, a branded grit or a heat-sealed build. The points then show what each paddle adds, or loses, from its specs, so a paddle with weak specs can score below 7. Starting at 0 wouldn’t change which paddle ranks higher, because every paddle gets the same start, but it would make good paddles look broken: a paddle with our top control rating would read 2.5 out of 10.
The Exact Points
Each category starts at 7. Add the points for every feature the paddle has.
Power
- Core 13 mm or thinner+1.5
- Core 14–15 mm+0.75
- Core 17 mm or thicker−1
- Weighs 8.3 oz or more+0.75
- Weighs 7.9–8.2 oz+0.25
- Weighs under 7.5 oz−0.5
- Elongated shape+1
- Hybrid shape+0.5
- Fiberglass face+0.75
- Hybrid (mixed) face+0.5
- Foam core+1.5
- Heat-sealed or one-piece build+0.75
Control
- Core 17 mm or thicker+1.5
- Core 16 mm+1
- Core 14–15 mm+0.25
- Core 13 mm or thinner−0.5
- Weighs 7.5–8.2 oz+0.25
- Standard shape+0.5
- Hybrid shape+0.25
- Carbon face+0.75
- Hybrid (mixed) face+0.25
- Fiberglass face−0.25
Spin
- Carbon face+1
- Hybrid (mixed) face+0.75
- Fiberglass face+0.25
- Long-lasting grit (a branded durable texture such as HexGrit or InfiniGrit)+1.5
- Basic grit (raw carbon or peel-ply texture)+0.75
- Elongated shape+0.75
- Hybrid shape+0.5
Sweet Spot
- 8.0 in wide or wider+2
- 7.75–7.99 in wide+1.25
- 7.5–7.74 in wide+0.5
- Core 16 mm or thicker+1
- Core 14–15 mm+0.5
- Heat-sealed, one-piece or extra edge weight+0.75
- Weighs 8.0 oz or more+0.25
- Shape comes from length: up to 16.0 in is standard or wide-body, 16.1–16.4 in is hybrid, and 16.5 in or longer is elongated, even when a brand labels it differently.
- Weight is the middle of the range the maker lists for the version we review (for example the 16 mm), not an average across versions.
- Face: a carbon face is carbon fiber. A face whose layup includes fiberglass alongside carbon scores as a hybrid (mixed) face, even when carbon is the top layer.
- Grit: raw carbon and peel-ply faces have a natural grit that wears with play, so they earn the basic grit points. Long-lasting grit is a branded durable texture the maker names, such as 11SIX24’s HexGrit, Selkirk’s InfiniGrit or Vatic Pro’s Evergrit. In the governing bodies’ terms, grit is surface roughness: UPA-A defines it as “the microscopic texture of a paddle’s Hitting Surface,” and USA Pickleball caps it with a roughness test (an average Rz of 30 micrometers or less). Neither publishes grit readings for individual paddles, so we go by what the maker says about the surface.
- Heat-sealed or one-piece: counts when the maker says the paddle is thermoformed, heat-sealed, hot-molded, unibody or one-piece, including brand names for the process such as Onix’s ThermoFused. Why it earns points: molding the face, core and edge together into one sealed shell makes the frame stiffer, so less energy is lost at the edges and joins and more goes back into the ball; a sealed edge also steadies off-center hits. That’s why it adds +0.75 for power and +0.75 for sweet spot. The rule follows a widely reported pattern and the makers’ own descriptions, not our measurements: no one publishes power data for individual paddles, and the +0.75 amount is our judgement.
- Extra edge weight: counts when the maker says weight is built into the paddle to enlarge the sweet spot, such as Selkirk’s MOI Tuning System.
Two rules then apply:
- Each category is rounded down to the nearest half point and kept between 1 and 9.5 (9.25 becomes 9; anything above 9.5 becomes 9.5). We don’t give any paddle a 10 because our scores are estimates from published specs, not lab tests, and a 10 would suggest a paddle is perfect. Small differences in the formula don’t reflect real differences on court, so we don’t show them, and rounding down means no paddle gets credit it only partly earned.
- The scale is a model, not a measurement. The point values are our judgment of how specs typically affect play. They come from widely understood relationships, such as thinner cores adding pop and wider faces adding forgiveness. They are not lab results, and two paddles with the same score can still feel different. So our scores are estimates, but they’re calculated the same way for every paddle from the maker’s published specs, so they’re reliable for comparing paddles side by side.
What Each Spec Does, in Plain English
Why each spec in the points table moves a score up or down. These are the general patterns the scale is built on, not measurements of any one paddle.
Power
- Core thickness: a thin core is springier and sends the ball back faster; a thick core soaks up the hit.
- Weight: more weight behind the ball pushes more energy into it, like a heavier hammer.
- Shape: a longer paddle swings faster at the tip, like a longer lever.
- Face: fiberglass flexes and springs the ball off the face; carbon is stiffer.
- Foam core: solid foam returns energy quickly, the biggest single power boost on the scale.
- Heat-sealed or one-piece build: one sealed shell is stiffer, so less energy is lost at the edges and joins.
Control
- Core thickness: a thick core absorbs pace, so dinks and resets stay soft and predictable.
- Weight: a midweight is easiest to steer: not so light it feels twitchy, not so heavy it feels slow.
- Shape: a shorter, wider paddle is easier to keep steady at the kitchen.
- Face: stiff carbon gives a consistent, predictable response; springy fiberglass is livelier and harder to tame.
Spin
- Face: carbon holds the ball a split second longer and grips it better than fiberglass.
- Grit: a rough surface grabs the ball. Branded grits are made to stay rough longer; the natural grit on raw carbon wears smoother with play.
- Shape: a longer paddle moves faster at the tip, so it brushes the ball with more speed.
Sweet Spot
- Face width: a wider face gives you more good hitting area. This is the biggest factor.
- Core thickness: a thick core spreads the hit out, so off-center shots still feel solid.
- Heat-sealed build or extra edge weight: a heat-molded frame, or weight built into the frame, stops the paddle twisting on off-center hits. This is about how the frame is built, not an edge guard.
- Weight: a little more mass keeps the paddle steadier on mishits.
The trade-offs: a thin core adds power and costs control; an elongated shape adds power and spin and costs control and sweet spot; a carbon face adds control and spin and costs some power. No paddle maxes out everything, which is why the four scores together say more than any one of them.
The Overall Research Score
The research score is the average of the four category scores, to one decimal place.
Differences under 0.3 are treated as a tie. A 9.4 and a 9.2 are effectively equal on our scale. When paddles are tied, our “best” picks say so and explain why we chose one.
Player-Type Scores
Different players want different things from a paddle, so we also score each paddle for four kinds of player. The higher the number, the better the match. These scores help rank paddles in the Paddle Finder and our best-of guides; reviews describe who a paddle may suit in plain words instead. They use the same four category scores, weighted differently for each player:
Beginners
Forgiveness first: sweet spot and control count most.
- Sweet spot40%
- Control35%
- Power15%
- Spin10%
Touch Players
Dinks, drops and resets: control counts most.
- Control45%
- Sweet spot25%
- Spin20%
- Power10%
Power Hitters
Drives, serves and put-aways: power counts most.
- Power45%
- Spin20%
- Sweet spot20%
- Control15%
Spin Players
Topspin drives and rolls: spin counts most.
- Spin50%
- Power20%
- Control15%
- Sweet spot15%
Example: the Selkirk OMNI’s Beginners Score
Its four category scores are sweet spot 9, control 9, power 9.5 and spin 9.5. Multiply each by how much it counts, then add them up:
| Score | How much it counts | Points |
|---|---|---|
| Sweet spot 9 | × 40% | 3.60 |
| Control 9 | × 35% | 3.15 |
| Power 9.5 | × 15% | 1.43 |
| Spin 9.5 | × 10% | 0.95 |
| Beginners score | 100% | 9.1 |
Missing or Conflicting Information
- Missing: if a manufacturer doesn’t publish a spec or feature, it earns 0 points and the review says what’s missing (for example “HEAD doesn’t specify the core material”). The one exception is the face material: if the maker doesn’t name it, we use the face material on the USA Pickleball approved list and say so.
- Conflicting: if the brand’s own sources disagree, we use its spec table over its marketing copy, and its current product page over older pages. If a conflict can’t be settled, we score the value that earns fewer points and explain why in the review.
- Ranges: weight ranges are scored at their midpoint.
How We Describe Paddle Builds
Every review lists the paddle’s build in one of four groups, taken from the maker’s own product page:
- Full-foam core: the core is foam, with no honeycomb.
- Honeycomb with foam edge walls: a honeycomb core with foam injected or built into the edges, such as JOOLA’s Hyperfoam Edge Wall or Selkirk’s FlexFoam Perimeter.
- Heat-molded honeycomb: the maker says the paddle is thermoformed, heat-sealed, hot-molded or unibody, or names its own molding process (such as Onix’s ThermoFused), with no foam walls listed. The review quotes the maker’s own term.
- Classic honeycomb: the maker lists none of the above.
Under each group we quote the maker’s own wording. Players often call these builds “Gen 1” to “Gen 4”, but there’s no official standard and most makers don’t number their paddles, so we only show a generation when the maker states it (for example, CRBN and 11SIX24 call some of their foam-core paddles Gen 4).
How Cores Are Scored
- Thickness counts most. It changes power, control and sweet spot (see the points table), and every maker publishes it. When a paddle comes in two thicknesses, we score the main version and say the other exists.
- A full-foam core adds +1.5 for power. Solid foam returns energy faster than honeycomb.
- Foam edge walls or perimeter foam don’t earn the foam points, because the core is still mostly honeycomb. The edge can still earn sweet-spot points if the paddle is heat-sealed or the maker describes extra edge weight.
- Honeycomb material isn’t scored. Polypropylene (most paddles), Nomex (players often describe it as firmer and louder) and aluminum are listed in each review’s specs, but no one publishes data on how much the material alone changes play, so they score the same.
- Brand names for cores, such as “Adaptive Dual Core” or “Channel Core”, are quoted from the maker and scored by their thickness and type.
The Two Approval Lists
Every review shows which approval list a paddle is on. There are two, and they serve different players:
- USA Pickleball: the list for sanctioned tournaments and most leagues in the US. It’s large, with more than 5,000 entries, and it’s the one most players need. See the USA Pickleball list.
- UPA-A: the United Pickleball Association of America’s list for pro events on the PPA Tour and Major League Pickleball. It’s smaller and pro-focused, with its own testing, so a paddle can be on one list and not the other. See UPA-A’s paddle rules.
When a paddle isn’t on a list yet but its maker says it meets that body’s rules, the review names the body and says the claim comes from the maker. Approval doesn’t change a paddle’s scores.
How Prices and Specs Are Checked
- Prices: checked automatically every day on each brand’s own store (HEAD’s prices are checked by hand). Every price shows the date it was checked. If a price hasn’t been confirmed in the last three days, we show it as a list price and point you to the store. We never describe a price as the lowest or guaranteed, and we aren’t an official retailer for any brand.
- Specs and USA Pickleball status: checked when a review is written and again in periodic brand audits. The dates are listed in each review’s sources.
Independence and Affiliate Relationships
We earn a commission when you buy through some links on this site, at no extra cost to you. Commissions never affect scores: every score comes from the formula above, applied the same way to every brand. Brands can’t pay for coverage, scores or placement. If a manufacturer ever provides us with a product or other compensation, we’ll disclose it in the relevant review, and it won’t change our assessment.
Every review carries a disclosure next to its price, and the full affiliate disclosure is linked in the footer.
How Reviews Are Updated
We update a review when:
- a price changes (daily check);
- a manufacturer changes specs, launches a new version or drops a paddle;
- a paddle is added to or removed from the USA Pickleball list;
- a reader reports an error and we confirm it;
- our method changes.
The “Updated” date on each review changes when its content changes. Significant corrections are noted in the review. To report an error, please contact us.
Method Changes
October 2026:
- Category scores are now rounded down to the nearest half point.
- Buyer feedback no longer adjusts scores; it previously could move a score by up to 0.5 in six reviews.
- Differences under 0.3 in the research score are treated as ties.
As a result, most scores went down slightly (by 0.3 at most), and every review was updated on the same day.
October 24, 2026:
- We wrote down how a few features are judged (face layups, grit, heat-sealed builds, edge weight and which version’s weight we use). The grit row in the points table was reworded to match how paddles were already scored: it previously listed peel-ply under long-lasting grit, but no peel-ply paddle had been scored that way.
- Applying the face rule to the Volair CMD (a carbon-and-fiberglass layup) moved the CMD HYB from 9.3 to 9.1 and the CMD WB from 9.4 to 9.3; the CMD EL stayed at 9.3. The Selkirk LUXX Control Air’s control rating was corrected to the 10 the scale gives, moving it from 8.6 to 8.8.
- Every rating is now capped at 9.5. Our scores are estimates from published specs, so none should claim a perfect 10. The 41 paddles that had a 10 in any category now show 9.5 there, and their research scores went down by 0.1 to 0.3; the order of our top-rated paddles didn’t change.
Trademarks
Paddle and brand names are trademarks of their respective owners and are used only to identify the products we review. Premium Pickleball Gear is not owned by, operated by or affiliated with any paddle manufacturer.

Next Step
See the Scale in Action
Every paddle is scored the same way. Compare any of them side by side, or see our top picks.
