Find Your Paddle
Paddles
Browse PaddlesPaddle DatabaseCompare PaddlesBest Pickleball PaddlesBest Pickleball PaddlesBy Playing StyleBest Power Pickleball PaddlesBest Control Pickleball PaddlesBest All-Court Pickleball PaddlesBy FeatureBest Pickleball Paddles for SpinBest Heavyweight Pickleball PaddlesBest Foam Core Pickleball PaddlesBest Carbon Fiber Pickleball PaddlesBy Skill LevelBest Pickleball Paddles for BeginnersBest Pickleball Paddles for Intermediate PlayersBest Pickleball Paddles for Advanced PlayersBy PriceBest Budget Pickleball PaddlesPremium Pickleball PaddlesReviews by Brand
11SIX24
Bread & Butter
CRBN
HEAD
JOOLA
Onix
Paddletek
Selkirk
Vatic Pro
Volair
All 85 Pickleball Paddle Reviews All Pickleball Paddle Brands 
Guides
Deals

Paddle Comparisons

Selkirk OMNI vs Boomstik: Which Paddle Should You Buy?

Dan · Editor, 3.5 DUPR player · How we score

Published

Selkirk’s OMNI and Project Boomstik look like twins: both come from Selkirk, both use a foam core with an EVA power ring, both have Selkirk’s layered carbon face with its InfiniGrit surface, and both come in an elongated shape and a wider Widebody shape. The difference is what each is built to do. Selkirk built the OMNI to do everything and the Boomstik for power. This guide compares them using Selkirk’s own published specifications and our spec-based research ratings. We haven’t play-tested these paddles.

Quick Answer

  • Look at the OMNI if you want one paddle for drives and the soft game. Selkirk says its ReactCore gives power, a plush feel on control shots and dwell for spin, and its edge weights can be moved by hand.
  • Look at the Boomstik if power comes first. Selkirk calls its BoomCore its most powerful core system ever, and its edge weights are clamped on to steady off-center hits.

The Core: ReactCore vs BoomCore

  • OMNI: Selkirk’s ReactCore, a PureFoam floating center with a PureFoam ring and an EVA power ring around it. Selkirk says it gives power, a plush feel on control shots and dwell to grab the ball for spin.
  • Boomstik: Selkirk’s BoomCore, PureFoam surrounded by an EVA power ring and fused together. Selkirk calls it its most powerful core system ever, with no core crush and no break-in period.

Both are full foam cores, which earn the biggest power bonus on our scale. Read foam core vs honeycomb for the background, or see every paddle like these on our best foam core pickleball paddles list.

The Edge Weights: Movable or Clamped

Both paddles come pre-weighted at the edge, which Selkirk says makes the sweet spot bigger. On the OMNI you can move the weights by hand, with marks to put them back, so you can tune the feel. On the Boomstik, Selkirk’s MOI Tuning System clamps the weights to the edge guard, and Selkirk calls them semi-permanent. Each paddle’s review lists Selkirk’s published swing and twist weights; see swing weight vs twist weight for what those numbers mean.

The Face

Both use Selkirk’s Multistrata carbon face, a layered T700 carbon build, with Selkirk’s InfiniGrit surface, which Selkirk says lasts much longer than a raw carbon texture. The Boomstik’s face is three layers of carbon, per Selkirk. Both have Selkirk’s octagonal handle, which Selkirk says gives more maneuverability and shot accuracy.

The Shapes

  • Elongated (OMNI and Boomstik): the longer paddle with the longer handle, for reach and room for a two-handed backhand.
  • Widebody (OMNI Widebody and Boomstik Widebody): the shorter, wider paddle with a bigger face, for forgiveness and control at the kitchen.

Each shape’s size and handle length are on its review. Our paddle shapes guide explains the trade-off between reach and sweet spot.

Boomstik vs OMNI: Which Should You Choose?

See every Selkirk paddle we review on the Selkirk brand page, or put any of these side by side with other paddles in our paddle comparison tool.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is better, the Selkirk OMNI or the Boomstik?

Neither is better across the board; it depends on your game. Selkirk built the Boomstik as its power paddle, around the core it calls its most powerful, so it suits players who attack from the baseline. Selkirk built the OMNI to do everything, with power, a plush feel on control shots and spin, so it suits players who want one paddle for drives and the soft game.

What is the difference between the Selkirk OMNI and Boomstik?

Both have a foam core with an EVA power ring and Selkirk's layered carbon face with InfiniGrit. The OMNI uses Selkirk's ReactCore, built for power, a plush feel and spin, with edge weights you can move by hand. The Boomstik uses the BoomCore, which Selkirk calls its most powerful core, with edge weights clamped to the edge guard.

Is the OMNI or the Boomstik more powerful?

Selkirk built the Boomstik for power and calls its BoomCore its most powerful core system ever. Selkirk built the OMNI to do everything, with power, control and spin. Each paddle's review shows its power rating on our scale.

Should I get the elongated or Widebody version?

The elongated OMNI and Boomstik add reach and a longer handle for two-handed backhands. The Widebody versions are shorter and wider, with a bigger face for forgiveness and control at the kitchen. Each shape's size is on its review.

Are the OMNI and Boomstik tournament approved?

Each paddle's review lists its approval in the spec table, matched to the official USA Pickleball and UPA-A lists. Check the exact paddle and shape you want.

Can you move the weights on the OMNI and Boomstik?

On the OMNI, yes: Selkirk lets you move its edge weights by hand, with marks to put them back. On the Boomstik, Selkirk clamps the weights to the edge guard and calls them semi-permanent.

Next Step

Ready to Compare Paddles?

Put the paddles from any guide side by side and compare them on the same research scale.

How We Score Paddles

Every paddle is built from the same few characteristics: core thickness, weight, shape, face material and grit. Each one pushes power, control, spin and sweet spot in a known direction, which lets us score any paddle from its specs.

Every score is worked out from the maker’s published specs with the same formula for every brand, so paddles compare fairly. We don’t play-test or measure paddles, and buyer reviews never change a score.

Each rating starts at 7 (a solid paddle with nothing extra), adds or loses points for each spec below, and rounds down to the half point. The top score is 9.5. The research score is the average of the four.

Power

Control

Spin

Sweet spot

Full method 

Scores by Player Type

Different players want different things from a paddle. So we take the same four ratings and count some more than others for each kind of player. The higher the score, the better the match.

Beginners

Forgiveness first: sweet spot and control count most.

Sweet spot 40% · Control 35% · Power 15% · Spin 10%

Touch players

Dinks, drops and resets: control counts most.

Control 45% · Sweet spot 25% · Spin 20% · Power 10%

Power hitters

Drives, serves and put-aways: power counts most.

Power 45% · Spin 20% · Sweet spot 20% · Control 15%

Spin players

Topspin drives and rolls: spin counts most.

Spin 50% · Power 20% · Control 15% · Sweet spot 15%

These use the same estimates as our other scores, so they’re best for comparing paddles side by side.

See the full method